Title: Mindfulness and Hypnosis: The Power of Suggestion to
Transform Experience
Author: Michael Yapko, PhD
Format: Book (also available on Kindle)
Source: Amazon
Price: $21
Rating: Excellent
While many of us in the vocational hypnosis community were
looking the other way, a technique that involves deep breathing, progressive
relaxation, focussed concentration, and a combination of guided and unguided
visualization has taken the therapy world by storm. The new buzzword:
Mindfulness—which is code for Buddhist meditation, carefully stripped of its
spiritual connotations and then put through rigorous testing by the scientific
research community. Not surprising to those of us who've been helping clients
with these techniques for years, the research has proven what we've known all
along: there is substantial benefit to be had from using concentrated attention
and suggestion to transform experience.
Fortunately, Michael Yapko was not looking the other way,
and in his new book, Mindfulness and Hypnosis, he lays out the
parallells between the two techniques. Perhaps because he is writing to an
audience familiar with mindfulness but woefully misinformed about hypnosis, he
states early in the book that the two techniques are not the same thing.
(This contradicts a comment from an Indian client of mine
who'd studied mindfulness meditation as she grew up in Mumbai; upon concluding
a hypnosis session, she said to me, "This is exactly the same as meditation!")
However, after that statement, Yapko goes on to show clearly
that Guided Mindfulness Meditation (GMM) and hypnosis use essentially the same
processes, all depending on the power of suggestion. Yapko provides
line-by-line analysis of typical GMM and hypnosis recordings to drive his point
home undeniably. He goes on in successive chapters to lay out the similarities
to such a degree that I find it hard to maintain the idea that hypnosis and
mindfulness are separated by much more than semantics—the dividing line, if
there is one, is very, very thin.
The final chapter, however, highlights the difference in a
powerful way—demonstrating that hypnosis as it is practiced in modern offices
goes one step beyond mindfulness in the service of the client. Yapko makes the
excellent point that those who have studied mindfulness can learn from the
centuries of research and exploration into the power of suggestion that the
hypnosis community can offer. Likewise, he acknowledges that hypnotists can
benefit by incorporating techniques of mindfulness into their practice.
Where it might have been tempting to write something
divisive—after all, to a hypnotist striving for years to point out the benefits
of these approaches, only to see mindfulness greeted like the prodigal son of
therapy, a little "I told you so" would be well deserved—Yapko makes
his points with brilliant diplomacy, clarity, and warmth.
Though, as I mentioned, Yapko is writing more for an
audience of mindfulness advocates than for hypnotists, the book is an essential
read for any hypnotist who wants to interact with professionals in our allied
disciplines. We need a common vocabulary, and as the rest of the world wakes up
to the value of what we've been teaching all along, we need to be able to interface
and communicate effectively about the benefits of what we do. Michael Yapko has
done us all a great service in writing this book.
Full Disclosure: Though I did not receive a gratis copy of Mindfulness
and Hypnosis for review, Dr. Yapko did generously replace my copy of his
seminal book, Trancework, when it was destroyed in an office fire last
year. Despite my sincere gratitude for his generosity and high regard for his
scholarship, I have gone on record elsewhere criticizing other works of his,
and we have disagreed privately, so I do not believe that his kindness in any
way colored my review of his latest book.
Great review James! Looking forward to reading it firsthand and continuing my incorporation and sharing of these mindfulness processes.
ReplyDeleteRick--I'm glad you enjoyed the review. Another work you might check out to help you with the practical application of mindfulness is Get Out of Your Mind and into Your Life by Steven Hayes.
DeleteThanks James for information on yapko technique
DeleteRegarding the statement, "This is exactly the same as meditation!" - Mindfulness is only one form of meditation. Not all forms of meditation follow the same process. So, your hypnosis session with him *could* have been just like his own meditation practice, but that does not mean it was just like mindfulness practice.
ReplyDeleteAnd mindfulness is not "Buddhist meditation" that has been stripped of anything. It is just mindfulness. It doesn't have any other objective, like 'enlightenment' (depending on what you think that word means).
I haven't read the book, yet, but I can see how someone might have made a connection in the first place. Neither, in my opinion, is actually about any "altered state" of consciousness. They are both more like a kind of focused awareness, with the main difference being that mindfulness is practiced with the intention of making that your normal state of awareness - always mindful, always now. While hypnosis intends to take that focus and direct it in such a way that the subject/client is able to make changes in their thoughts/behaviors.